• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • DOPT ORDERS 2020
  • FinMin Orders 2020
  • Railway Orders 2020
  • Contact Us

7th Pay Commission Latest news

Central Government Employees News

  • DOPPW Orders
  • 7th Pay Commission
  • Dearness Allowance
  • Dearness Relief
  • CSD Price List
  • Defence
    • Defence Pension
You are here: Home / 7th Pay Commission / The Seventh Pay Commission, recommendations and impact

The Seventh Pay Commission, recommendations and impact

August 25, 2016 pcadmin 1 Comment

5534831280_cf3ccd2f02_bThe Seventh Pay Commission, recommendations and impact

The government has increased the salaries of the government servants in keeping with the recommendations of the Seventh Pay Commission. There is euphoria in the market. Auto sales, for example, are set to pick up. The government servants are expected to buy more numbers of bigger cars with their increased incomes.

This will certainly provide a boost for the automobile sector. But, this is only a half truth. The money paid to the government servants will not come at the swing of the magic wand. This money will be taken from the pockets of someone else. The final impact of the Pay Commission will depend upon the increased demand from government servants and the effect on those who will pay the increased taxes to pay these increased salaries, as reported by thehansindia.com.

About one-half of the taxes come from Income Tax. These are mostly paid by the rich. The other half of the taxes comes from excise duties, service tax and sales tax.  These are known as indirect taxes. These are paid by the rich and the common man alike. Let us say one-half of the indirect taxes are paid by the rich and one-half by the common man.

Overall, then about three fourths are paid by the rich in the form of Income Tax and indirect taxes and one fourth of the taxes are paid by the common man in form of indirect taxes. Let us say, the government collects an additional Rs 100 of taxes to pay increased salaries to the government servants. Rs 75 of this will come from the rich and Rs 25 from the common man.

The payment of increased salaries of Rs 100 to the government servants would deprive the common man of Rs 25 of his income. He would not be able to buy the motorcycle or the refrigerator that he had planned to buy. The consumption of rich who pay the tax will also reduce. Let us say their consumption is reduced only by Rs 25. On the whole then, the consumption or demand in the market shall be reduced by Rs 50.

The increased salary of Rs 100 will be paid to the government servants. The minimum emoluments of the lowest government servant inclusive of DA, pension and other benefits would be about Rs 40,000 per month or more than Rs 5 lakh per year. I reckon they will save one-half of the additional salary and consume one-half. Thus, the demand in the market shall be increased by Rs 50 due to the increased consumption by them.

The net impact on the demand in the market will be zero. The demand will increase by Rs 50 from the government servants and the demand will reduce by Rs 50 from the taxpayers. The taxpayer will buy less number of motorcycles while the government servants will buy increased numbers of cars. Payment of increased salaries to the government servants thus involves a shift of consumption from the common man to the government servants.

Thus a section of the economists are rightly saying that implementation of the Pay Commission will revive the fortunes of the automobile sector. They are ignoring, however, that this will be accompanied with a parallel reduction in demand in motorcycles. The same collection of additional tax of Rs 100 would have an entirely different impact if the government spent the money in building highways, e-governance portal or space research.

In that case, the demand in the market would increase by the entire Rs 100 spent by the government. The National Highways Authority of India will buy more steel and cement to build the highways. The reduction of demand, on the other hand, will be only Rs 50.  A reduction of demand of Rs 25 will take place because of the increased taxes paid by the common man and another reduction of demand of Rs 25 will take place because of the increased taxes paid by the rich.

In the end, the reduction in demand would be Rs 50, while the increase in demand will be Rs 100. The correct formula for reviving the economy is to use increased tax collections for investments rather than paying increased salaries to the government servants. The impact on the economy in the second cycle will be even more dramatic. Paying increased salaries to the government servants will increase the chasm between the common man and them. Walk into any village in the country and you will see that the government servants have invariably made pucca houses.

Speak to a jeweler or a property dealer and they will tell you that most purchases are being made by government servants. These same government servants are being paid even more amounts by taking the money from the common man. This widening chasm between the common man and the government servants will lead to an increase in social dissension. Of course, every young man today wants to join the army of government servants so that he can participate in the loot of the country. However, few will succeed and rest will be left disenchanted.

The result in the second cycle would be entirely different if the taxes collected from the common man were spent for making highways. The farmer would be able to reach the vegetables produced in his field to the market easily. The loss of incomes borne by him due to paying increased taxes will be made up by the increase in incomes from the construction of new highways.  Such an approach will be in keeping with the welfare state mandate of the Constitution.

I had seen a study done by the World Bank few years ago. It had compared the salaries of government servants with per capita GDP in countries of the world. It was found that the salaries of government servants in India were five times the per capita GDP and this difference was highest in the world. The Seventh Pay Commission will further accentuate this already perverse distribution of the national income. The practice of paying huge salaries to government servants was instituted by the British masters in order that they could suppress the people of the country. Alas! The same story continues. Author was formerly Professor of Economics at IIM Bengaluru.

Article courtesy: Dr Bharat Jhunjhunwala

IndiaLiveToday

Filed Under: 7th Pay Commission

Also Read

Linking of CGHS Beneficiary ID with the ABHA ID

Linking of CGHS Beneficiary ID with the ABHA ID

January 20, 2023 By pcadmin Leave a Comment

Linking of CGHS Beneficiary ID with the ABHA ID F.No. 44/67/MCTC/CGHSGovernment of IndiaMinistry of Health & Family WelfareDepartment of Health & Family Welfare Nirman Bhawan, New DelhiDated the January, 2023 OFFICE MEMORANDUM SUBJECT: Linking of CGHS Beneficiary ID with the ABHA … [Read More...] about Linking of CGHS Beneficiary ID with the ABHA ID

Implementation of Railway Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2016

Implementation of Railway Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2016

January 19, 2023 By pcadmin Leave a Comment

Classification of Railway Services consequent upon implementation of Railway Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2016 GOVERNMENT OF INDIA (BHARAT SARKAR)Ministry of Railways (Rail Mantralaya)(Railway Board) PC-VII No. 201File No. PC-VII/2017/RSRP/2 RBE No. 16/2023New Delhi, dated: … [Read More...] about Implementation of Railway Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2016

Early Closure of Offices in connection with Republic Day Parade/Beating Retreat Ceremony/At Home Function during January, 2023

Early Closure of Offices in connection with Republic Day Parade/Beating Retreat Ceremony/At Home Function during January, 2023

January 19, 2023 By pcadmin Leave a Comment

Early Closure of Offices in connection with Republic Day Parade/Beating Retreat Ceremony/At Home Function during January, 2023 No.16/3/2023-JCAGovernment of IndiaMinistry of Personnel Public Grievances and Pensions(Department of Personnel and Training)Establishment (JCA) Section North Block, … [Read More...] about Early Closure of Offices in connection with Republic Day Parade/Beating Retreat Ceremony/At Home Function during January, 2023

Grant of Transport Allowance at double the normal rates to persons with disabilities employed in Railways

Grant of Transport Allowance at double the normal rates to persons with disabilities employed in Railways

January 12, 2023 By pcadmin Leave a Comment

Grant of Transport Allowance at double the normal rates to persons with disabilities employed in Railways GOVERNMENT OF INDIA/ भारत सरकारMINISTRY OF RAILWAYS/ रेल मंत्रालयRAILWAY BOARD/ रेलवे बोर्ड S.No. PC-VII- 202. RBE No.10/2023 No. PC-V/2017/A/TA/I(E) New Delhi Dated: – … [Read More...] about Grant of Transport Allowance at double the normal rates to persons with disabilities employed in Railways

Review of CSS Officers under FR 56 (j) and Rule 48 of CSS (Pension) Rules, 1972

Review of CSS Officers (Under Secretary) under FR 56(j) and Rule 48 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972

January 9, 2023 By pcadmin Leave a Comment

Review of CSS Officers (Under Secretary) under FR 56(j) and Rule 48 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 REMINDER No. 21/1/2022-CS.I(U)Government of IndiaMinistry of Personnel, Public Grievances & PensionsDepartment of Personnel & Training(CS.I Division) 2nd Floor, 'A' Wing, Lok Nayak … [Read More...] about Review of CSS Officers (Under Secretary) under FR 56(j) and Rule 48 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Padmanabhan Vijayaraghavan says

    August 25, 2016 at 3:05 PM

    There are many studies and reports that higher income groups from companies not paying the due tax taking advantage of various loopholes. Some companies have crores of rupees shown as profit pay less than 30% tax . it is impossible in case of salary people.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

All About Pension

All about Pension

Latest DOPT Orders

Addendum for early closure of all the offices falling in the premises of Parliament House & Rashtrapati Bhawan in c/w forthcoming Republic Day

Early Closure of Offices in connection with Republic Day Parade/Beating Retreat Ceremony/At Home Function during January, 2023

Review of CSS Officers (Under Secretary) under FR 56(j) and Rule 48 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972

Year-End- Review of DoPT(Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions)-2022

Extension of the LTC block year 2018-21 (extended) for a period of three months

Latest Finmin Orders

Compendium of Instructions regarding grant of House Rent Allowance to Central Government employees – FINMIN

CGEGIS 1980: Table of Benefits of saving funds from Oct to Dec 2022

Non-Productivity Linked Bonus (ad-hoc bonus) to Central Government Employees for 2021-22

FINMIN : Dearness Allowance to Central Government employees effective from 01.07.2022.

Compendium of Instructions regarding grant of Transport Allowance at double the normal rates to persons with disabilities employed in Central Government

Latest Railway Orders

Implementation of Railway Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2016

Computer Advance Interest Rate 2022-23 for Railway Employees

Eligibility of married disabled child for family pension – Railway Board order

Grant of Leave to Probationary officers: Railway Board

Productivity Linked Bonus to all eligible non-gazetted Railway employees for 2020-2021

Categories

Copyright © 2023