• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • DOPT ORDERS 2020
  • FinMin Orders 2020
  • Railway Orders 2020
  • Contact Us

7th Pay Commission Latest news

Central Government Employees News

  • DOPPW Orders
  • 7th Pay Commission
  • Dearness Allowance
  • Dearness Relief
  • CSD Price List
  • Defence
    • Defence Pension
You are here: Home / 7th Pay Commission / 7th pay panel’s draft report riddled with dissent notes

7th pay panel’s draft report riddled with dissent notes

November 12, 2015 pcadmin Leave a Comment

7th pay panel’s draft report riddled with dissent notes

The seventh Pay Commission’s draft report to determine the new salary structure for the 5.5 million civil servants in the central government has got riddled with several dissent notes. The notes, mainly about bringing in parity between the top-ranked Indian Administrative Service (IAS) and the specialised central services, argue that it will widen the talent base available to the government to deliver increasingly complex services to a demanding population

But the dissensions could exacerbate differences at the top of the bureaucracy in the Government of India, already reeling from the impact of pay-related problems for the retired armed forces personnel who have demanded ‘one rank one pension’.

“There is a strong case for considering talent in the government rather than being confined to choices within some cadres,” former expenditure secretary Dhirendra Swarup told Business Standard. Swarup is one of the few non-IAS officers who became secretaries in the government, under former finance minister Jaswant Singh.

The notes are also a first for the Pay Commissions, set up every 10 years by the central government to revise the pay and allowances of central government employees. In the fifth Pay Commission, economist Suresh Tendulkar had put in a dissent note but it was on a macro theme suggesting a pruning of the bureaucracy and relating wages to performance.

But this time the notes reflect the sharp differences that have come up among the different cadres of government services about their pay and promotion avenues. There is a larger issue here. All the services taken together make up fewer than 150,000 people within the central government tasked with a mammoth level of administrative responsibility for a country of 1.3 billion people. So, frustrations among them could have far-reaching repercussions.

These men and women operate in a rigidly differentiated world through an appointment system that places them in cadres. The cadres almost mirror the caste differences in the larger society. The top-most cadres are the all-India services that include the IAS, Indian Police Service and Indian Forest Service. Of them, the IAS are the most numerous, at 4,572 according to the Civil Survey Report of 2010, written by former cabinet secretary, K M Chandrasekhar.

Below them are about 45 cadres clubbed as central civil services, which include the IFS, IA&AS and IRS.

The impact of this pecking order came out in the open recently in the list of empanelled officers for the post of 60 additional secretaries. These posts rank just one notch below that of the secretaries, who function as heads of department or ministries in the government. Of those empanelled, only three (railways, income tax and audit & accounts services) were from the non-all India services. Swarup said the numbers were even lower than those until the 1990s, when there were at least five non-IAS officers in the central government ministries. At joint secretary and senior levels, positions up to those of secretaries (senior administrative grade) in central ministries, the share of other services is minuscule when compared with IAS. Yet, this is where policies are shaped.

At the heart of the difference is a two-year increment offered to IAS officers when they join vis-a-vis other cadres. Since seniority within the government is decided on pay scale, the higher start assures these officers of a higher position at each grade. But as the IRS officers and others in their representations have pointed out, this makes it impossible for them to compete for additional secretary and secretary posts in the ministries.

But Chandrasekhar counters it saying officers from most non-IAS services have enough options to be promoted within their services. “There is need for both specialists and generalists in the civil services. The Indian government is a massive structure that demands many different skill sets”.

To correct some of the problems, the 2010 report had suggested setting up of a Central Civil Services Authority for officers from all the services after they completed 13 years of service. Each officer would get to choose an area of specialisation for the rest of their career. It has not been implemented so far.

The report of the Pay Commission, headed by Ashok Kumar Mathur, a former judge of the Supreme Court, was held up due to Bihar Assembly polls. The commission was given a four-month extension in August. Besides Mathur, the others in the commission are Vivek Rae (IAS) as full-time member, besides part-time members Meena Agarwal (Indian Railway Accounts Service) and Rathin Roy, director, National Institute of Public Finance and Policy (NIPFP). The commission is attempting to paper over some of the differences before the report goes to Finance Minister Arun Jaitley. The commission did not respond to requests for an interaction on the contents of the report.

The differences have become so sharp that social media platforms like WhatsApp have been flooded with often derogatory comments from opposing cadres about each other, a first of sorts. But both Swarup and Chandrasekhar held that such comments might not be serious enough to test the smooth functioning of the officers from different services when they were posted together.

Source : Business Standard

Filed Under: 7th Pay Commission, 7th Pay Commission News Tagged With: 7th Pay Commission, 7th Pay Commission News

Also Read

Ceiling of Rs. 5 Lakh on Subscription in General Provident Fund

Ceiling of Rs. 5 Lakh on Subscription in General Provident Fund

May 23, 2023 By pcadmin Leave a Comment

Ceiling of Rs. 5 Lakh on Subscription in General Provident Fund Government of West BengalFinance DepartmentGroup-J Memo No: 027-F (J) WB Date: 04/05/2023 MEMORANDUM Subject:- Ceiling of Rs. 5 Lakh on subscription in General Provident Fund (West Bengal Services) in a financial … [Read More...] about Ceiling of Rs. 5 Lakh on Subscription in General Provident Fund

GISS, 1987 – Table of Benefits upto July, 2023

GISS, 1987 – Table of Benefits upto July, 2023

May 23, 2023 By pcadmin Leave a Comment

GISS, 1987 – Table of Benefits upto July, 2023 GOVERNMENT OF WEST BENGALFINANCE DEPARTMENTAUDIT BRANCH No. 031-F(J) W.B. Date: 11.05.2023 MEMORANDUM SUBJECT: State Government Employees Group Insurance Scheme, 1987 – Table of Benefits under Savings Fund for the year of cessation of … [Read More...] about GISS, 1987 – Table of Benefits upto July, 2023

Disbursement of Railway Pension through Private Sector Banks

Disbursement of Railway Pension through Private Sector Banks

May 23, 2023 By pcadmin Leave a Comment

Disbursement of Railway Pension through Private Sector Banks Government of IndiaMinistry of RailwaysRailway Board RBA No. 16/2023 No. 2010/AC-II/21/10/Pt IV New Delhi, dated 15.5.2023 Pr.Financial Advisors,All Zonal Railways & PUS Pr. Chief Personnel Officers,All Zonal Railways … [Read More...] about Disbursement of Railway Pension through Private Sector Banks

Clarification on calculation of ex-gratia for the employees of CPSEs following IDA

Clarification on calculation of ex-gratia for the employees of CPSEs following IDA

May 18, 2023 By pcadmin Leave a Comment

Clarification on calculation of ex-gratia for the employees of CPSEs following IDA W-02/0029/2021-DPE (WC)Government of IndiaMinistry of FinanceDepartment of Public Enterprises Public Enterprises Bhawan,Block 14, Lodi Road,New Delhi 110003.Date: 16.5.2023 CORRIGENDUM Subject: … [Read More...] about Clarification on calculation of ex-gratia for the employees of CPSEs following IDA

TN Govt increases Rate of Dearness Allowance by 4% from 1st April 2023

TN Govt increases Rate of Dearness Allowance by 4% from 1st April 2023

May 18, 2023 By pcadmin Leave a Comment

TN Govt increases Rate of Dearness Allowance by 4% from 1st April 2023 Government of Tamil Nadu2023 MANUSCRIPT SERIES FINANCE [Allowances] DEPARTMENTG.O.(Ms).No.142, Dated:17th May 2023.(Sobakiruthu, Vaigasi-03 , Thiruvalluvar Aandu 2054) ABSTRACT ALLOWANCES - Dearness Allowance - … [Read More...] about TN Govt increases Rate of Dearness Allowance by 4% from 1st April 2023

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

All About Pension

All about Pension

Latest DOPT Orders

Grant of fund for modernisation of Non-Statutory Departmental Canteen located in Central Government Offices

General Election 2023: Grant of Paid holiday on day of Poll for General Election in Karnataka, 2023

Reimbursement of Children Education Allowance (CEA) to Central Government servants having Divyang Children

Addendum for early closure of all the offices falling in the premises of Parliament House & Rashtrapati Bhawan in c/w forthcoming Republic Day

Early Closure of Offices in connection with Republic Day Parade/Beating Retreat Ceremony/At Home Function during January, 2023

Latest Finmin Orders

CGEGIS 1980 – Tables of Benefits for the savings fund for the period from 01.04.2023 to 30.06.2023.

Dearness Allowance to Central Government employees effective from 01.01.2023 – FINMIN Order

Compendium of Instructions regarding grant of House Rent Allowance to Central Government employees – FINMIN

CGEGIS 1980: Table of Benefits of saving funds from Oct to Dec 2022

Non-Productivity Linked Bonus (ad-hoc bonus) to Central Government Employees for 2021-22

Latest Railway Orders

Disbursement of Railway Pension through Private Sector Banks

Dearness Relief to Railway pensioners from Jan 2023

State Railway Provident Fund Interest Rate from April 2023 to June 2023

Timely verification of Caste/Community Certificates – Railway Board Order

Timelines for completion of APAR to Railway Employees for 2022-23

Categories

Copyright © 2023